First impressions. They'requite important. But they'realsoquitedifficult. Especially when you're a singerwithstagefreight.
Singer Ralph George struggleswithstagefreight. According to his Bandcamp site forseveralyearsnow. He usedtobe a singerthattook classic rock-songsandturnedthemaroundtoprovide his listenenerswith a complete new andfrequentlyunrecognizableversion. It allowedhimtoattrackt fans. It allowedhimtoestablish a career in rock music.
Thenthestagefreight hit him. He became a stay-at-home musician—in thelikes of Nick Drake perhaps—andusedthe internet to contact his fans andcommunicatewiththemthrough songs.
However, earlythisyear he announced he startedworking on anactual album—oposedtothe (sometimes) weird covers he sang for his followersandfriends on the internet—withself-writtenmaterial. The recluse singerbecamethehardworking singer-songwriter.
Thisannouncementprobablyshocked his manyfollowers, because he now releases the E.P. In A Room With... A collection of songs by a variety of artists. Andeverythingaboutthis E.P. says: "this is me, but only in part."
As youexpect, whenitconserns a home-recording, the E.P. starts with tape-hizz. Which sets thetone of theentirecollection. This is musicrecordedwith a couple of befriendedmusicians on a saturdaynight, over a couple of beers.
His 70s approach, which he promises on his Bandcamp is truly met. Even though Mr. Brightside is a prettyrecent hit for The Killers, Ralph's approach is most definately70s:thegrumpyguitar, thedistant drum andsynthesizer. And his voice sounds like itjustwalked out of a New Wave gig at CBGB's or something. And he singsitwell. He singsit like it's fit for a TV talent show.
One Of Usintroducestheacousticguitar, semi-angelic background voicesandsomewhisperedsecretmessages at thebeginning of the song. Andwhilethat'sniceversion of the song, Shut Up And Dance offers nothing new. In fact, thisversionstayssoextremly close theoriginal, it is in factan obsolete song.
Suprising, however is the take on the U2 classic With Or Without You. This is nothing but voiceandacousticguitar. However, he does somethingwiththe pace. It sounds like the song you'veheard a million times, but thesudden stopping andstarting of theguitar, thepullingandpushing of thevoice, turnsitintosomethingorganicwhichtriestounderlinewhatit's like to live with or without someone. This is anintimateconversationbetweentwopeoplethatultimately leads to 'andyougiveyourselfaway'. And theguitarendstheconversationquiteabruptly.
In A Room With... is not bad or lousy. It's justsomething a lot of artists put out there. It's the kind of album youplaywhenyou'rein themiddle of a garden party withfriends. It's nice in the background, but itdoesn't make you stop theconversationyou're in at thevery time.
However, itcanbeconsideredanintroductionto Ralph George's voice. Soyoucan get usedtoitbefore he releases his self-writtenmaterial next year.